via�Feds ‘confused,’ watchdog says – Woodstock Sentinel Review – Ontario, CA.�
The federal government is making environmental decisions and spending billions based on “incomplete, poor or non-existent information,” according to a new report from the federal environment watchdog.
The commissioner of the environment and sustainable development investigated the government’s handling of the environmental impact of the oilsands projects as well as its climate change plans.
Commissioner Scott Vaughan noted the government’s own scientists admit they don’t know the full impact of the oilsands on water quality, fish and fish habitat, land, air and wildlife.
But Ottawa did take one step earlier this year by committing to build a monitoring system that will gather information on the impact of the oilsands in northern Alberta, Saskatchewan, and the Northwest Territories.
Vaughan called the proposed new system “a game changer.”
Still, he said it was up to parliamentarians to decide whether the feds should halt current development in the Alberta oilsands until the system is up and running.
Vaughan also found the Conservative government earmarked $9.2 billion for climate-change measures across seven departments last year — but wasn’t able to track spending.
“Right now, it’s looking to us to be disjointed, confused and non-transparent,” Vaughan said of Ottawa’s management of the money, adding it came with mediocre results.
He pointed to internal Environment Canada analysis that found it cost up to $92,000 to reduce emissions by a tonne for at least one program.
“A tonne of carbon on the Alberta market today is about $15. So I think getting some basic financial information is important to do the value-for-money count on this.”
NDP environment critic Megan Leslie called the Conservatives “bad managers.
“We can’t even assess if these plans are working,” she said.
Vaughan also found Canada has overshot its greenhouse-gas emissions target under the 2007 Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act by 31%.
The Tories’ most recent commitment to address climate change is to drop greenhouse gases by 17% from 2005 levels by 2020.
Vaughan said it would be next to impossible for Canada to meet those commitments.
The government said it’s working to improve its policies and to meet its target.
Environment Minister Peter Kent said Kyoto was no longer on the table, but he was confident Canada would meet the other commitments made in Copenhagen and Cancun.
“Stay tuned and stay with us,” he said.